Guee Mag II - Cageless Water Bottle

This review is for Guee Mag One Cage Free System - the Mag II is the next generation cageless design

Review by John Stevenson (Road.cc)

If you have a small frame, or bikepacking luggage taking up your main triangle, the Guee Mag One is a clever combined bottle and cage that pivots out sideways thanks to its nifty magnetic attachment.

 

 

Instead of a cage, the system has a mount that incorporates neodymium-iron-boron (NIB) magnets. Since their invention in 1982 by General Motors and Sumitomo Special Metals, NIB magnets have become ubiquitous in applications that require high-power permanent magnets. They're the reason earbud headphones work, they allow modern hub dynamos to produce useful amounts of power and without them ebike motors would be much bigger and heavier.

> Find your nearest dealer here(link is external)

The Guee Mag One has four NIB magnets, two in the mount and two in the piece that fits into a moulded recess in the bottle. You attach the mount to your bike with the included pair of M5 dome-head 3mm Allen key screws and you're away. Get the bottle reasonably close to the mount, and the magnets do the rest. It's not the same as putting a regular bottle into its cage, but it's just as easy, and rapidly becomes second nature. Lightly sprung plastic latches on the bottle help to keep it in place.

It stayed put while I bounced over some of the roughest local drove roads. Cambridgeshire's fens are intercut with knackered old concrete-surfaced byways, often with steps or gaps between the slabs, or chunks of the surface simply missing. Some of them were tarmacced over sometime in the late Paleolithic and that tarmac is now full of holes. If a bottle doesn't jettison over this stuff it'll stay put anywhere.

To remove the bottle, you twist it clockwise. That means it doesn't matter if there's something in the way of the upward path of a traditional bottle. The Mag One is therefore perfect for bikes with restricted space in the frame, whether it's because they're very small or because there's a frame bag under the top tube getting in the way.

The bottle comes out to the right-hand side of the bike if you've mounted it on the down tube. If you're left-handed, that might be a problem. I certainly found it awkward to remove the bottle with my left hand, but I'm very right-handed. Left-handed folks who are used to compensating for a right-handed world might have less difficulty. With the Mag One on the seat tube, it comes out to the left, which is definitely awkward for me. It'd be nice if Guee made versions that released clockwise and anti-clockwise. That way you could get one of each and fit them to the down tube and seat tube to match your dominant hand.

The bottle magnets sit in a plastic moulding that's recessed into the bottle, and can be removed if you want to put your bottle through the dishwasher. Make sure you put it back in the right way up, following the arrows, or the magnets will repel those in the mount and it won't work. You lose a little capacity because the mounting is moulded into the bottle. A standard water bottle like a Camelbak Podium can hold just over its claimed capacity of 710ml. The nominally 600ml Guee bottle will take 645ml if you fill it right to be brim. Most of the Podium's extra capacity comes from it being a few millimetres fatter than the Guee bottle.

Judged as a bottle, the Mag One does the job just fine. Its screw-on lid fits snugly and its silicone pull-valve dumps plenty of water into your mouth. It's quite stiff though, requiring a decent tug to get it open. The main body is made from food grade polypropylene and has no discernible effect on the taste of the contents. The polypro formulation here is a bit stiffer than most, but that's a very minor niggle.

Guee isn't the first company to come up with a magnetic bottle mount. Vincero Design's Stratus system has been around for a while, and works well. The Stratus design doesn't provide the space saving you get from the Mag One, though its low-profile mount looks tidier when you don't have a bottle on the bike. Swings, roundabouts.

At £45 the Guee Mag One is expensive; over three times the price of a typical good quality bottle and cage. However, you can get the same thing under other labels for about £30 (see below). That's a reasonable premium for the space saving it offers and the extra parts and mouldings necessary to get there, but £45 is a bit silly.

> Find more road.cc reviews of bottle cages here

I think Guee has missed a trick in making the mount work only with a proprietary bottle. The conventional bottle and cage is one of very few remaining universal standards on bikes, and a small player isn't going to change that, however clever its alternative. If the magnets and latches from the Guee bottle could be fitted to a conventional bottle, that would open up the market for the Mag One. I'm imagining something like a pair of hose clips (but much tidier) to attach the bottle part of the system. Then you could use your favourite bottle, or a pair of Zefal's one-litre Magnum bottles if you want to carry lots of water, or you could carry anything else that's roughly the diameter of a water bottle.

This bottle and cage pairing here is available under at least three brands. The Restrap Mag Bottle(link is external) is exactly the same thing and so is the Fidlock Bottle Twist(link is external). The Guee bottle is actually marked Fidlock on the bottom. Fidlock is a German company that makes buckles and fasteners like the magnetic buckle on some Abus helmets, so it seems likely it originated the design.

Whichever version you get, the Guee Mag One is a well-executed answer to the problem of cramming water bottles into tight spaces. It fits to your bike just like any other bottle cage and it stays put on rough roads better than some cages I've used.

Verdict

Clever answer to the question "How do I fit a water bottle on a small frame or under a frame bag?"

 

 

See original article here - https://road.cc/content/review/228762-guee-mag-one-cage-free-system

Set Title

XPEDO Platform Pedal - ZED - DH/ All MTN - CrMo Spindle, Low Profile, Extra Large, 380g | BLACK
CODE: XMX27AC-BK
BARCODE: 883511002363
PRICE: $139.94 (Inc GST)
  In stock (25+)Low stock (25+)Out of stock (25+)
PARKLOCK BRUNSWICK 5 digit COMBO U LOCK
CODE: PRKBRUNS
BARCODE:
PRICE: $50.00 (Inc GST)
  In stock (25+)Low stock (25+)Out of stock (25+)
GUEE Cageless Bottle Set - MAG-II - Water Bottle and Magnetic Mount
CODE: GU-WB02-X1A1-GY
BARCODE: 4716112724098
PRICE: $69.95 (Inc GST)
  In stock (25+)Low stock (25+)Out of stock (25+)
MARS ONE GEAR OUTER WORKSHOP - Black (lubricated liner) to suit to 4mm cable Length: 50m BOX
CODE: M1-WGO-CSH001-50X
BARCODE:
PRICE: $99.95 (Inc GST)
  In stock (20)Low stock (20)Out of stock (20)
ATA Freewheel - 1/2 x 1/8, 16T, Black/ Nickel
CODE: FWATKD16
BARCODE: 712038763344
PRICE: $14.99 (Inc GST)
  In stock (25+)Low stock (25+)Out of stock (25+)
KWT PANNIER RACK REAR -  ADJUSTABLE 24-29 INCH  - DISC BRAKE COMPATIBLE - FLAT PACKED UNASSEMLBED
CODE: RA6809
BARCODE: *RA6809*
PRICE: $34.95 (Inc GST)
  In stock (25+)Low stock (25+)Out of stock (25+)
YABAN 9 SPD CHAIN - SOLID PIN & PLATE -  1/2 X 11/128  116L Pin Length 6.4mm Colour: Silver/Silver
CODE: YBNS9S2
BARCODE: 4710887190126
PRICE: $34.95 (Inc GST)
  In stock (25+)Low stock (25+)Out of stock (25+)
GUEE Bar Tape - SL ELITE - Celeste/ Green
CODE: GU-BT06-X5A1-GN
BARCODE: 4716112724050
PRICE: $49.94 (Inc GST)
  In stock (25+)Low stock (25+)Out of stock (25+)
FUNN Handlebar - KINGPIN - Ø35, 785mm Wide, 15mm Rise, 8° Back, 5.5° Up, RED
CODE: FN-HB17KP785J15-03
BARCODE: 4712931187687
PRICE: $99.95 (Inc GST)
  In stock (2)Low stock (2)Out of stock (2)
FUNN Stem - CROSSFIRE - Ø35, 35mm, 0° Rise, Steer 1-1/8
CODE: FN-HS18CF035J00-03
BARCODE: 4712931189872
PRICE: $84.94 (Inc GST)
  In stock (2)Low stock (2)Out of stock (2)
DISSECTOR 27.5 X 2.40 WT EXO 3C MAXX TERRA TR FOLDING ETB00231000
CODE: MX-DIS2724EXO3CTR
BARCODE: 4717784038209
PRICE: $82.95 (Inc GST)
  In stock (25+)Low stock (25+)Out of stock (25+)
MICROSHIFT Rear Derailleur - R9 - 2 x 9/10 Speed, Mega 30-34T
CODE: MSH-RD-R43M
BARCODE: 657993147399
PRICE: $50.00 (Inc GST)
  In stock (12)Low stock (12)Out of stock (12)
TORCH 20 X 2.2 FOLDING 120 TPI SILKSHIELD
CODE: TOR22K
BARCODE: 4717784032573
PRICE: $52.95 (Inc GST)
  In stock (25+)Low stock (25+)Out of stock (25+)
Subscribe now to our newsletter »

Be first to know about our latest news, promotions and products.

Login